CARM Phase 2 Compliance: Avoiding 2025’s $50K Penalty Threshold

With CARM Phase 2 now mandatory as of February 2025, many SMEs are unprepared for CBSA's financial security requirements. This lack of readiness creates significant risk, as the penalty threshold can reach $50,000 for non-compliance.


Understanding CARM Phase 2 Requirements

The Customs Assessment and Revenue Management (CARM) system represents Canada’s most significant customs modernization initiative in decades. Phase 2 introduces mandatory financial security posting, with an April 19, 2025, deadline. Importers must now:

  • Calculate appropriate bond amounts based on CBSA’s Risk Assessment Matrix.
  • Integrate ERP systems with CARM reporting requirements.
  • Implement dual reporting capabilities for goods under multiple trade agreements.
  • Train staff on CBSA’s Trusted Trader Portal functionality.
  • Companies failing to meet these requirements face severe consequences, including shipment delays, penalty assessments, and potential suspension of import privileges.

Strategic Compliance Planning

Forward-thinking importers are implementing a three-stage approach to CARM compliance:

Assessment: Conduct a comprehensive review of current customs processes, identifying gaps in financial security requirements and reporting capabilities.

Implementation: Develop a phased roadmap addressing immediate compliance needs while building long-term capabilities.

Optimization: Leverage CARM’s digital infrastructure to reduce brokerage fees and streamline customs processes.

Our automotive sector clients have reduced brokerage fees by up to 28% through strategic compliance planning, simultaneously eliminating potential penalties while improving operational efficiency.

Key Deadlines to Remember

  • February 26, 2025: You are now in the CARM Phase 2 implementation period
  • April 19, 2025: Final deadline for financial security posting
  • January 19, 2026: Expiration of late accounting penalty grace period

Next Steps for Importers

  • Determine your financial security requirements based on annual import volume.
  • Evaluate your current customs broker’s CARM capabilities.
  • Implement staff training on CARM Portal functionality.
  • Consider a comprehensive CARM readiness assessment.

With proper planning and implementation, CARM Phase 2 can transform from a compliance burden into a strategic advantage, reducing costs and improving supply chain visibility.
Companies implementing blockchain traceability typically follow a three-phase approach:

  • Assessment: Evaluate current traceability systems and identify gaps in documentation, verification, and compliance.
  • Implementation: Deploy blockchain solutions that integrate with existing systems while ensuring all supply chain partners can participate effectively.
  • Optimization: Continuously refine the system to improve data quality, reduce friction points, and maximize compliance benefits.
Share the Post: